If you ever want to hear real fear in a business owner’s voice, ask them about an avoidable payroll mistake they’ve lived through. For many businesses, these errors quickly require financial adjustments, and cause employee concerns, and compliance issues that demand careful management.
The reality is simple: payroll is either right or wrong. There’s no middle ground. And when it’s wrong, the consequences can hit your business like a freight train. That’s why it’s so important to know the common payroll mistakes businesses make to understand where things tend to go off track and how you can protect your business from the potentially catastrophic consequences of these errors.
Key Takeaways:
To the uninitiated, payroll is like assembling a 1,000-piece jigsaw puzzle while blindfolded. Every state has its own labor laws. Regulations change frequently. Classification rules are tricky. Tax codes are complex. Even the content of pay stubs has legal requirements.
As a result, here are some of the most common payroll compliance mistakes businesses make:
The issue with payroll errors isn’t just that they’re expensive to fix; it’s that they tend to snowball. One incorrect classification or missed tax payment can trigger audits, back payments, and legal actions that drag on for years.
To get a sense of how payroll problems unfold, consider a few scenarios that reflect issues many businesses have run into.
One common situation involves mistakenly classifying employees as independent contractors. While this kind of misclassification might seem like a harmless shortcut at first, it can trigger serious consequences. In cases like this, state labor boards often step in, audits are launched, and businesses can face six-figure liabilities made up of back wages, fines, and tax penalties. On top of that, employees may file lawsuits under California’s Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA), which adds legal fees and additional penalties to the equation.
These types of cases have become so common that California recently updated the PAGA law, allowing businesses to reduce penalties by up to 85% if they can demonstrate that they took reasonable steps to “cure” the violations within 33 to 60 days of being served, such as being proactive, auditing, fixing, checking processes. Violations that can be cured now include claims for minimum wage, overtime, meal and rest breaks, necessary expense reimbursement, and all requirements for itemized wage statements, among others. There are FAQs available (HERE) about how penalties could be limited by this proactivity.
In another scenario similar to many enforcement actions, many businesses overlook 401(k) contributions for long periods of time. In these cases, money is being withheld from employee paychecks but is not properly deposited into their retirement accounts on time, which is a violation of federal ERISA regulations. Once discovered, the company faced penalties from the Department of Labor as well as a wave of frustrated employees who lost trust in their employer’s ability to handle payroll accurately.
While the specifics may change, these examples highlight a bigger reality: payroll mistakes don’t happen in isolation. They tend to snowball, growing more complicated and costly the longer they go unaddressed.
For employees, payroll mistakes cut straight to the core of job satisfaction. People expect to be paid correctly and on time. When that doesn’t happen, it can feel personal and erode trust.
Imagine an employee whose paycheck bounces, or who discovers their overtime wasn’t included, or realizes their 401(k) contributions never got deposited. Suddenly, they’re wondering if they can trust management at all. Morale takes a hit, productivity drops, and high performers may start looking for jobs elsewhere. Once employee trust is broken, rebuilding it is no small task.
Even when mistakes are caught and fixed, the anxiety can linger. Employees worry every payday that something might go wrong again. This kind of stress creates a toxic workplace culture where even minor frustrations become amplified.
Beyond compliance mistakes, there’s another payroll risk that can sneak up on businesses: internal fraud.
Payroll fraud schemes can include:
According to the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners, payroll fraud affects roughly 27% of all businesses and often goes undetected for years. In addition, because payroll usually involves sensitive financial information, it’s often handled by a small team, making internal checks even more critical.
The best defense? Strong internal controls, regular audits, and separating payroll duties among multiple people to avoid conflicts of interest.
Avoiding payroll problems doesn’t depend on perfection. It comes down to having reliable processes in place from the start.
Here are a few best practices that can save your business enormous headaches:
For businesses in California, PAGA reform offers some breathing room. The new law gives employers who can show they took reasonable compliance steps the opportunity to reduce penalties if violations occur. But that’s no substitute for doing things right the first time.
Getting payroll right is essential, and Next Level Strategies is here to help you navigate it without breaking a sweat. With the right systems and expert guidance, you can avoid costly payroll mistakes, stay compliant, and maintain the trust of your team.
We’re committed to helping you protect your business, support your people, and keep your peace of mind. Reach out to us today by filling out the form below or call us at 415-876-NEXT to make payroll one less thing to worry about.
Reach out to our team of HR experts today!
Common payroll mistakes include misclassifying employees, incorrect tax withholdings, and missing deadlines for payments and filings.
Payroll errors can result in penalties, audits, lawsuits, and damage to employee trust, exposing the business to serious legal risks.
To prevent payroll fraud, implement strong internal controls, regularly audit payroll records, and separate payroll duties among different employees.
Next Level Strategies © 2025. All Rights Reserved. | Privacy Policy | ADA Compliance | Site By
